A stationary bike is the perfect choice for your home gym—it offers a range of low-impact versatile cardio workouts that you can adjust to any fitness level and time. You can diversify your indoor workouts by incorporating interval training, using different resistance levels, or opting for longer endurance rides.
Upright and recumbent bikes are the two most popular models when it comes to selecting a stationary bike for home. In this article you will find a detailed comparison of both exercise bikes to determine which one is more suitable for your needs and fitness goals.
Upright vs. recumbent bike: What's the difference?
Upright bikes resemble traditional outdoor bikes: the bike seat is small, the pedals are placed right below the saddle, and the handlebars are at the chest level. You have to engage your core, back, and arm muscles to maintain the correct position on an upright bike.
On the other hand, recumbent bikes have a larger, more comfortable seat with back support, the pedals are placed in front of the seat, and there is a second set of handlebars on the sides next to your hips. You can keep a more relaxed and reclined position during your ride on a recumbent bike. Recumbent bikes are larger and will take up more space in your home gym.
Upright vs. recumbent bike: What muscle groups are engaged?
Both cardio machines will predominantly engage your lower body muscles. While riding, you will work the following muscle groups:
- The quadriceps, calves, shins, and hamstrings are engaged to perform a pedal stroke.
- The glutes are the main source of force for your pedal stroke.
- Hip extensions are used to get legs back to their starting position after the stroke is finished.
An electromyography study showed that there was no statistically significant difference in muscle workload during a recumbent bike and an upright bike exercise. This means that both stationary bikes are equally effective in toning your lower body muscles.
If you’re looking to engage a wider range of muscle groups during your cycling workout, an upright bike provides the better option. In addition to your lower body muscles, an upright bike engages:
- Core muscles including abdominals and erector spinae which work as stabilizers.
- Back muscles, the quadratus lumborum muscle and iliopsoas, which maintain your position and support the spine.
- Biceps and triceps which are used when you hold the handlebars.
While both bikes will provide you with a great cardio workout, an upright bike provides the better option when it comes to engaging more muscle groups.
Upright vs. recumbent bike: What is better for weight loss?
When it comes to weight loss, high-intensity interval training (HIIT) results in a higher calorie burn compared to regular training of the same length. You will also continue to burn additional calories after HIIT thanks to an elevated metabolism post-workout and an increased afterburn effect.
An upright bike is more universal and usually offers more types of workouts, including both HIIT and steady-state cardio. In contrast, a recumbent bike is suitable mostly for low-intensity steady-state training due to its reclined position, making it harder to push the pedals when intensity is increased. In addition, you engage more muscle groups riding an upright exercise bike which also helps you burn more calories.
As a result, your recumbent bike training will have lower caloric expenditure than an upright bike session. On average, 1 hour of cycling on a recumbent bike burns 20% fewer calories than the same training on an upright bike (320 calories vs 400 calories for a low-intensity training). Adding several HIIT sessions per week will make this difference even larger.
Recumbent bikes do still offer low-intensity steady-state workouts, which done in your fat-burning zone (60%-70% of your maximum heart rate), are still effective for losing weight. Most recumbent bikes offer 8 to 24 levels of resistance so you can adjust workout intensity to increase the calorie burn. Another option is to combine your indoor cycling training with other types of full-body HIIT workouts to maximize the effect.
Upright vs. recumbent bike: Training time
Recumbent bike training can be quite time-consuming compared with an upright bike due to its low-intensity steady-state nature. On the other hand, an upright bike lets you effectively cut your training time with HIIT sessions, making a 20-minute HIIT workout as effective as a 45-minute steady-state cardio workout.
CAROL Bike can reduce your training time even further—to just 15 minutes a week. CAROL Bike’s signature REHIT workout consists of just 2×20-second sprints, done within a 5-minute workout. REHIT stands for Reduced Exertion High Intensity Interval Training and its HIIT taken to the next level. It is scientifically proven to be the most effective cardio workout, delivering superior health and fitness benefits in 90% less time compared to regular cardio.
CAROL’s AI optimizes each workout to your ability and fitness level, making sure you’re getting the most out of every workout. Just 3x REHIT sessions per week is proven to improve your cardiovascular fitness by 12%, and reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes by 62%—in just 8 weeks. It’s a moment of effort you can always master to build a habit that lasts.
CAROL burns over twice as many calories, minute-per-minute vs. traditional exercise, largely thanks to afterburn.
Upright vs. recumbent bike: cardiovascular fitness
Both types of exercise bikes are effective for improving your cardiovascular fitness – strengthening your heart muscle, regulating blood pressure and glucose levels, reducing unhealthy cholesterol levels, and increasing capillary density.
A study of young healthy adults during moderate-intensity exercise on a recumbent and upright bike showed that a reclined position puts less strain on the cardiovascular system and allows participants to recover faster to their resting heart rate. A recumbent bike can therefore be more beneficial for people with cardiac limitations or recovering from a heart attack, however you will not be able to perform REHIT, the most efficient and effective cardio workout.
Upright and recumbent bikes: Conclusion
Here’s a short recap of the main differences between the 2 types of exercise bikes:
Both an upright exercise bike and a recumbent exercise bike can provide you with a solid cardio workout at home. You can choose the model most suitable for you depending on your preferences, fitness level, and health condition.
If you prefer a gentler, low-impact cardio workout, a recumbent bike should be your first choice. Those who prefer a more intense workout and would like to improve their performance should opt for an upright bike. Upright bike training will help you achieve your fitness goals such as weight loss or improved VO2max faster and more effectively.
Ready to achieve more in less time? CAROL is the smartest, most effective exercise bike with workouts backed by science. Learn how CAROL Bike can transform your fitness journey today.
Got a question? Let's book a call.
All our experts have MSCs in Exercise Science, and they’re here to answer your questions. Whether it’s about the science behind CAROL Bike, or general fitness advice, whatever’s on your mind—we’re here for you.
